Interesting TACs of the Week (September 26 – October 2, 2015)

 

Summary – A top-down review of interesting calls and comments made last week in Treasuries, monetary policy, economics, stocks, bonds & commodities. TACs is our acronym for Tweets, Articles, & Clips –our basic inputs for this article.

Editor’s Note: In this series of articles, we include important or interesting Tweets, Articles, Video Clips with our comments. This is an article that expresses our personal opinions about comments made on Television, Tweeter, and in Print. It is NOT intended to provide any investment advice of any type whatsoever. No one should base any investing decisions or conclusions based on anything written in or inferred from this article. Macro Viewpoints & its affiliates expressly disclaim all liability in respect to actions taken based on any or all of the information in this article. Investing is a serious matter and all investment decisions should only be taken after a detailed discussion with your investment advisor and should be subject to your objectives, suitability requirements and risk tolerance.

 

1.QE4 to Detox the Fed? 

NY Fed President William Dudley is a smart guy besides being an uber-dove. He was interviewed by Jon Hilsenrath at the WSJ Breakfast confab on Monday, September 28. Hilsenrath was totally focused on the trajectory of Fed rate hikes in 2015 & 2016. So he missed the import of what Dudley said to him five minutes into the interview:

  • “… economy is not really that strong & monetary policy isnt quite as easy as people think; if monetary policy was super accomodative right now, then we should see growth much faster than 2% +; that suggests equilibrium interest rates consistent with neutrality of monetary policy are lower than current … “ 

If current “monetary policy is not as easy” as people think, if a “super accommodative monetary policy” would be needed for higher growth and since the current rate is zero, was this unsolicited comment a hint that at least Dudley is already thinking of another QE. WSJ didn’t answer our question and our usual FinTV folks ignored this comment as well. Why did we bother? Why didn’t we ask the one & only Rosie? We didn’t have to because he volunteered his QE comments in his appearance on CNBC SOTS on Thursday: 

  • if things get bad, they will do QE; people are talking about the negative dot; that might have been planted

Well, things got bad in a hurry:

  • Friday – Gluskin Sheff ?@GluskinSheffInc -Rosenberg: Tack on downward revisions, decline in the workweek, and the “real” payroll number was -265k. You read that right.

Friday’s 142,000 number was the 4th consecutive disappointing number and 6th out of last 7.

  • Carl Riccadonna ?@Riccanomix – September Jobs Report: Will the deceleration continue?

Embedded image permalink

If you think, that’s bad, look at the story the revisions tell:

  • SoberLook.com ‏@SoberLook – Chart (via @NickatFP): Extensive downside revisions to US payrolls figures in 2015
Embedded image permalink

 

What does this do to the Fed’s reputation? Rick Santelli said on Tuesday that “the Fed has become toxic“.  A different term was used on Friday:

  • fred hickey ?@htsfhickey – Sept&Aug jobs reports miserable.Manufacturing in tatters.Atlanta FED Q3 GDP forecast 0.9% growth. Global econ. rots. Faith in Fed to plunge

Look at the above revisions chart again. It shows higher revisions to NFP during periods of QE and a quarter or so afterwards. So the only way for the Fed to detox its reputation is to launch QE4. If you think that is crazy, look at the action in financial markets on Friday. After a massive plunger of almost Dow 350 points, from 100 up pre-NFP to down 250 at the open, we saw an unrelenting 450 point rally marked by a couple of large buy programs to close the Dow up 200 points. Commodities rallied even harder with Emerging Markets handily outperforming the S&P and the 30-5 year yield curve steepened by 5 bps. This is pure QE action. Jeffrey Gundlach also pointed to hope in the markets on Friday:

  • “The reason the markets aren’t going lower is people are holding and hoping

What could investors be hoping for after the awful NFP number on Friday? US economy rebounding, China shaking off its slowdown or QE-manna from Fed heaven? At least one indicator is already back to pre-taper days:

  • Macro Man ?@Macr0man – 4th vs 8th ED contracts now flatter than the closing price on the day the Fed announced the taper 
Embedded image permalink

 

But what about rate hike expectations built into the markets?  Bloomberg points to:

 

2.Bonds

Treasury yields fell off the proverbial cliff after the NFP number. The rally was instantaneous and kept going until its high just after 10:00am. 

  • tom keene ‏@tomkeene – the 10-year yet to stabilize .@markets .@TheStalwart

Embedded image permalink

But the long maturity was not the star of the day. That honor belonged to the 5-year yield which dropped to a 1.22% handle at the peak of the Treasury rally. The yield curve bull-flattened on Friday and for the entire week with 30-year yield falling 14 bps while the 5-year yield falling by 19 bps. TLT up 2.5% for the week and EDV, the zero-coupon ETF, was up 3.7%.

But TLT began falling after its high after 10:00am and closed down almost 2 points below its high of the day. TLT also closed below its 200-day moving average. But that is the exception. The yields on the rest of the on-the-run curve closed well below their 200-day moving averages. This is another reason Friday’s action suggests QE4 thinking in the markets.

Credit was a different story.

  • Bloomberg Markets ?@markets – It’s been a terrible week for the credit market http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-10-02/it-s-been-a-terrible-week-for-the-credit-market …  via @tracyalloway
Embedded image permalink

 

Gundlach said junk bonds are vulnerable: “I’ll think about buying when it stops going down every single day.” The high yield acted badly on Friday despite the rally in other asset classes:

  • Terry Danish ?@TerryDanish – HIGH YLD bond prices continue to sink like a diving tuna
Embedded image permalink

 

Aren’t they oversold yet?

  • Mark Newton ?@MarkNewtonCMT – High Yield $JNK has gotten VERY stretched in ST, but requires a close back > 35.83 from 8/24 for confidence of bounce
Embedded image permalink

 

What about Investment grade credit?

  • Tuesday – Charlie Bilello, CMT ‏@MktOutperform – US Investment Grade spreads up to 174 bps, widest level since Sep 2012. Cycle low was 106 bps in June 2014. $LQD
Embedded image permalink

 

When do stocks bounce without credit? Under a QE scenario, empirically speaking.

 

3. US Stocks

The rally in stocks was mega impressive. It featured buy programs and a steady unrelenting buying pressure. It closed on the highs of the day. At times, it felt like a buying panic. But isn’t that par for a very oversold, poorly positioned market in October, a period which is famous for major bottoms & significant rallies into year-end? This rally actually began on Thursday when the broad indices rallied from a down 211 Dow to close in the green. The futures indicated a nearly 100-point rally before the NFP.  Then came the post-NFP deluge with a down 250 point open.

  • Sara Sjölin ?@sarasjolin – Markets jitters are back at panic levels, says Credit Suisse and backs up with this chart http://www.marketwatch.com/story/markets-are-back-at-panic-levels-says-credit-suisse-2015-10-02 …

Embedded image permalink

But this was October, sentiment was awful, and large players were underweight. No one wants to get gored by a Q4 bull and no long-oriented player wants to miss out on a Q4 rally. So, 

Embedded image permalink
To his credit, @NorthmanTrader didn’t merely post the above photo at the end of the day. He asked the important question earlier in the day and posted an emerging pattern:
  • At some point bears must ask themselves: Why doesn’t 1900 $SPX break? The answer may potentially lie in this emerging inverse pattern. A revisit to this week’s overnight highs would break the neckline and could trigger a move into the 1970 and above 2000 upon confirmation. Likewise a close below 1900 $SPX will likely negate the pattern:
What was his view at the end of the day?
  • What a trap. Massive daily bullish outside reversal, huge weekly bottoming candle combined with double bottom and turning and crossed MACDs. This will take some time to digest:

SPX W

3.1 Bottom in?
  • Ryan Detrick, CMT @RyanDetrick – 10/4/11 was the last time the $SPX was down 1.5% at the lows and closed up 1.4%.  That is nearly four years to the day people.  Huh.  $SPY
This was picked up & amplified:
  • Urban Carmel ?@ukarlewitz – Urban Carmel Retweeted Ryan Detrick, CMT Does history repeat? 10/4/11 was the 2011 low
And,
  • StockTwits ‏@StockTwits – This is how the stock market bottoms. On average. Fantastic share by @JLyonsFundMgmt: http://stks.co/h3DjG  $SPY
Embedded image permalink
Open & shut, right? Not quite.
3.2 Close Green?
  • Ryan Detrick, CMT ?@RyanDetrick – Think about this.  N=22 $SPX down 6% or more after 3Q.  Has NEVER been green by year end.  Can ’15 break it?  $SPY
Embedded image permalink
This was amplified by:
  • Mark Newton ?@MarkNewtonCMT – Mark Newton Retweeted Ryan Detrick, CMT – 9 Times out of 22 occurrences the -6%+ Returns Heading into Q4 got WORSE by year-end-4 of those times Nearly Doubled
3.3 Leadership Change?
Leadership changes usually result from a major correction. So if this correction is over with a bottom in, then should we expect a leadership change? Yes, has been our belief. 2011 was the relative top in emerging markets. So we wonder whether 2015 becomes the relative bottom in emerging markets. They are so hated that their fundamentals don’t have to show a bottom. That can follow a move in emerging equity outperformance.
Jim Paulsen of Wells Capital has made a similar case but he comes to this conclusion because he expects an up move in interest rates. Our view is the opposite. We think the contagion has finally entered the US economy & the US market which is overvalued relative to EM.  We think the Fed will not raise rates in 2015 or even in Q1 2016. So we think the US Dollar will not rally and we think US rates will trend down. This, if it materializes, will provide a tailwind to commodities and to commodity oriented emerging markets which have been sold to the point of being abandoned.
This week changed some smart minds as we noticed.
  • Sunday, September 27 – J.C. Parets ‏@allstarcharts – NEW POST: Emerging Markets Are Still A Problem http://allstarcharts.com/emerging-markets-still-a-problem/ … $EEM $SPY $FCI $EWZ $ILF $RSX $EPI $EWY
Then, 
  • Wednesday – J.C. Parets ‏@allstarcharts – Doing my global review, appears countries with exposure to commodities are the ones putting in bullish divergences & poised to mean revert
Also,
  • Wednesday – Charlie Bilello, CMT ‏@MktOutperform – Ratio of commodities to stocks is turning up (ever so slightly) from what has been a persistent downtrend for years
Embedded image permalink
Followed by:
  • Ryan Detrick, CMT ?@RyanDetrick – Sugar is up 10% the past five days.  Silver up 5% in October already.  Few things more hated than commodities here.  $SGG $SLV
So which market do you think of when you want to play a vicious oversold rally in commodities? Brazil would be the answer of most people. And guess what EWZ did this week – up 7% handily beating the S&P rally of 1%.
What about Copper? Well, Carl Icahn is already big into copper via Freeport-McMoRan.
Let us be clear. We are not making a long term or even an intermediate term call for outperformance of EM over US. We think simply and commodities for a Q4 2015 rally look fine to us.  
4. Oil
Is there a more important commodity than oil? Is there a commodity that can rally for more reasons than oil? Before us is a Saudi Arabia that might need more money soon, a Russia that has done the unthinkable by reentering the middle east with its military & bombing US-backed rebels. We have a possibly weaker Dollar and lower US interest rates. And USO rallied by 5% with OIH and XLE followed narrowly behind.
  • Bloomberg Business ?@business – Bulls sense a potential turning point in U.S. crude-oil prices http://bloom.bg/1VuQMFL

The article states:

  • With U.S. crude-oil prices having fallen by about half in the past year but trading in a narrow band of roughly $40 to $50 for the past two months, bulls sense a potential turning point. Storied commodities investor Jim Rogers hinted strongly at it in an interview today, Bloomberg news reported, without quite committing. And indeed, overnight in New York, the WTI contract added a buck a barrel, as this chart shows.
Syria drove it higher, jobs drove it lower
What about the supply side?
  • Bloomberg TV ?@BloombergTV – Merrill Lynch: Oil producers are moving to balance production, demand http://bloom.bg/1VuJO3O
Isn’t there a correlation between the Canadian Dollar and Oil?
  • J.C. Parets ?@allstarcharts – NEW POST: Here’s Why Canadian Dollars Are About To Explode Higher  http://allstarcharts.com/canadian-dollars-are-about-to-explode-higher/ … $USDCAD $6C_F $FXC $UUP

10-2-15 usdcad d

The article by Parets lays out his case in detail with charts. Below is his conclusion:

  • I’m a weight-of-the-evidence guy. To me, the bearish implications here for USD/CAD (bullish for Canadian Dollar Futures) are very skewed in one direction. Price-wise this is a buy 100 times out of 100. The Commercial Hedgers, who we consider the smart money, are pretty much as long as they’ve ever been. Sentiment-wise, our data suggests that Canadian Dollars today are more hated then they have ever been (our data goes back 25 years). What more can you ask for?
  • Risk management-wise, which is the most important thing, I think the market has made it very clear for us. We only want to be long Canadian Dollars if we are above this week’s lows. That’s it. Below that and there is nothing to talk about. In the case of shorting USD/CAD, we only want to be short below this week’s highs. It’s that simple. Target-wise, sentiment unwinds like this can be very powerful and can take a long time to complete. I would be very patient here taking profits as I think this one has a long way to go.
5. Gold
Gold & Silver rallied on Friday with GDX up 8%. Carter Worth of CNBC Options Action said that the downtrend in Gold might be coming to an end. The charts are the story of his presentation. His call Buy GDX. Gold has risen to the bottom of its downtrend line. If GDX just gets up to its downtrend, it will get to $17 – 18% up from Friday’s close.

Send your feedback to [email protected] Or @MacroViewpoints on Twitter

 

1 Comment

  1. Today ,Indian Print Media has said that hope of Fed Reserve delaying rate hike is fueling global rally. It also says weaker than expected Job data in the US cheered markets elsewhere . The net result may be that Fed Reserve may not hike rates in 2015 !
    But sentiment remains cautious with Volatility Index( a measure of near term risks by the traders ) closing marginally lower.
    Gagan Rai

Comments are closed.